Head to head · 33 criteria compared TradeDay wins this comparison (5 against 4). Take Profit Trader stays relevant for traders whose priorities differ from the average.
Founded in Florida in late 2021, Take Profit Trader runs a three-tier path — Test, then PRO, then PRO+ on the live market — with withdrawals available from day one on a funded account. It excludes no countries, which is rare. The point to watch is the drawdown type changing between tiers, which catches many traders out.
Criteria won: 4 / 33
TradeDay was founded in Chicago in 2020 by two former institutional market professionals, and that background shows in the rulebook: no daily loss limit, news trading and scalping allowed, and withdrawals available from day one. The May 2026 rework dropped static drawdown accounts in favour of two paths, Quick Pay and Fast Pass.
Criteria won: 5 / 33
Cheapest evaluation for a 100 K account.
Take Profit Trader
$330
TradeDay
$240
| Full comparison | Take Profit Trader | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Trust | ||
| Score | 76/100 | 80/100 ✓ |
| Trustpilot | 4.3/5 | 4.6/5 ✓ |
| Founded | 2021 | 2020 ✓ |
| Headquarters | US | US |
| Pricing | ||
| Entry price | $150 | $131 ✓ |
| Price for a 100 K account | $330 | $240 ✓ |
| Refundable fee | No | No |
| Reset price | — | — |
| Account sizes | 150 K | 150 K |
| Rules | ||
| Steps | 1 | 1 |
| Profit target | 6 % | 6 % |
| Max daily loss | — | — |
| Max total drawdown | — | — |
| Drawdown type | Trailing (end of day) ✓ | Trailing intraday |
| Time limit | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Consistency rule | 50 ✓ | 30 |
| Min trading days | 3 ✓ | 5 |
| Payouts | ||
| Profit split | 80 % | 80 % |
| Max profit split | 90 % | 90 % |
| First payout | 0 days | 0 days |
| Payout frequency | Daily, on demand from the first day | On demand from the first day, minimum $250 per withdrawal |
| Payout methods | — | — |
| Scaling plan | No | No |
| Max allocation | 150 K | 150 K |
| Trading | ||
| Platforms and instruments | ninjatrader, tradingview, tradovate, rithmic, quantower ✓ | tradovate, rithmic, ninjatrader, tradingview |
| Instruments | futures | futures |
| Leverage | — | — |
| News trading | Yes | Yes |
| Weekend holding | No | No |
| Expert Advisors | — | — |
| Copy trading | — | — |
| Scalping | Yes | Yes |
| Hedging | — | — |
Choose Take Profit Trader if… Choose TradeDay if… Take Profit Trader keeps 90 % of profits, allows a first withdrawal after 0 days, then pays Daily, on demand from the first day. TradeDay keeps 90 % of profits, allows a first withdrawal after 0 days, then pays On demand from the first day, minimum $250 per withdrawal. Payout frequency deserves as much attention as the split itself: a slightly lower share paid every two weeks compounds faster than a headline percentage locked behind a monthly cycle and a long first-withdrawal delay.
Take Profit Trader is the only one of the two to offer quantower. Platform choice is not cosmetic: order execution, available order types and the reliability of your automation all depend on it, and switching mid-evaluation is rarely possible.
TradeDay has been running since 2020, 1 years longer than Take Profit Trader. On Trustpilot they sit at 4.3/5 and 4.6/5 respectively. Our trust pillar scores them 83/100 and 85/100, which weighs age, corporate transparency and public payout evidence. In an industry with no financial regulator overseeing these evaluations, longevity and a verifiable payout history are the closest thing to a guarantee.
TradeDay opens at $131 against $150 for Take Profit Trader, a moderate gap on the smallest account. At the reference size of 100 K the comparison is $330 for Take Profit Trader against $240 for TradeDay. The headline fee is rarely the real cost, though: what matters is the price of a reset after a failed attempt, whether the fee comes back on the first payout, and whether an activation fee appears when you move to a funded account. Compare those three lines in the table above before deciding on price alone.
Take Profit Trader applies a trailing (end of day) drawdown. TradeDay applies a trailing intraday drawdown. This is the single most consequential difference between the two. A static drawdown is measured once, from the starting balance, and never moves; a trailing drawdown follows your equity upward, so a winning streak raises the floor you can no longer fall below. Intraday trailing is stricter still, because it tracks unrealised peaks reached inside the session — profit you never actually banked can permanently raise your loss threshold.
No discount code is published without being checked on the firm’s own website. An unverified deal does not appear here.
See the discounts
